brian@briancuban.com
Brian Cuban Brian Cuban
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Presentations
    • Law Schools
    • Bar Associations/Legal Profession Events
    • Addiction/Mental Health Recovery
    • Law Firm Programs
    • Eating Disorder Recovery
    • Suicide Awareness
  • Testimonials
  • Upcoming Events
  • Photo Gallery
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • MEDIA
  • The Recovery Minute
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Presentations
    • Law Schools
    • Bar Associations/Legal Profession Events
    • Addiction/Mental Health Recovery
    • Law Firm Programs
    • Eating Disorder Recovery
    • Suicide Awareness
  • Testimonials
  • Upcoming Events
  • Photo Gallery
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • MEDIA
  • The Recovery Minute
  • Home
  • Uncategorized
  • Free Speech And Hate Speech In Social Networks

Uncategorized

20 Oct

Free Speech And Hate Speech In Social Networks

  • By bcuban
  • In Uncategorized
  • 1 comment

I came across an interesting piece about cyber-bullying of  gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender teens on Facebook and the steps the social network was taking to combat it.  This is nothing new.  As long as their are people, there will be hate speech.  It’s the human condition. As a representative correctly point out, Facebook is just as vulnerable to this condition as other cross-sections of society.

What I found interesting was the hate speech/free speech discussion. When does free speech become hate speech in social networks like Facebook?”  I was at first confused.  Is not  hate speech for the most part free speech?   That is unless it incites others to imminent violence, threatens the President Of The United States and some other narrow exceptions.  Why make the confusing distinction?  The reason the distinction was valid in this article was that it was specifically referring to Facebook and not the brick and mortar world.  Facebook is a community that attempts to emulate 1st Amendment ideals of free speech but that’s where it ends. It ends there because Facebook is a private company.  As such, the 1st Amendment and traditional free speech values have no practical bearing.  Free speech and hate speech are just terms of art within the network to be adjusted by the network to best suit the interests of the network.  Translation? Free speech and hate speech are whatever Facebook and other social networks say they are at any given moment.

So what are they?  Two years ago, I debated this very issue with Facebook representatives relating to Holocaust Denial.  I felt that Facebook Groups promoting Holocaust Denial were in themselves “hateful content” as outlined in Facebook’s Terms Of Service and should have been removed from the site.  Facebook felt differently.  I even presented my thoughts  to a group of employees at Facebook corporate offices.  While not agreeing with their position,  I came to understand their point of view about having internal standards to which employees can look at content and not have to make value judgments about a particular type of speech. Without such standards Facebook employees assigned to deal with these issues would be overwhelmed with disputes over content that one person may find “hateful” and another felt was legitimate expression. They could not hire enough employees to deal with these types of disagreements.  As one employee put it, Facebook was  looking for “binary certainty” in making these decision on “hateful content”.

There is the rub.  What is the binary standard?  To this day, to my knowledge, Facebook has never released or publicly stated how they evaluate “hateful content”.  Where and how do they draw the line?  I have an idea how they do it because I was privy to internal exchange with their employees.  Why not tell everyone.  Why not some transparency.  The same transparency many employees acknowledged was lacking  when I spoke there.  Two years later, nothing much has changed with regards to “free speech” and “hate speech”  The general user perception is that it is whatever Facebook says it is.   At least in the brick and mortar world I can pull up The Constitution and Supreme Court opinions that guide me.  That standard does not represent the beliefs of all Facebook users across the world but for better or worse that is the standard Facebook uses. It’s transparent.  Emulate that aspect as well.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Tags:cyber bullyiingFree Speechhate speechholocaust denial
  • Share:
bcuban
Want Brian To speak at your law firm, bar association or general recovery event? He can be reached at brian@addictedlawyer.com.

You may also like

We Need Compassion More Than Ever

  • May 20, 2020
  • by bcuban
  • in Law Practice Wellness
I am one of many lawyers who struggle with depression. I say “many” because according to the 2016  Hazelden...
A Letter To My Siblings
February 3, 2020
The Greatest Gift My Father Gave Me
December 11, 2017
From The Clubs To The Courtroom
December 8, 2017

    Comments

  1. AStaganaga
    January 2, 2015

    Lol.. people today use facebook as their diary!

Comments are closed.

Categories

  • Above The Law
  • Addiction
  • Alcoholism
  • Body Dysmorphic Disorder
  • Bulimia
  • Bullying
  • Depression
  • Eating Disorders
  • Eating Disorders
  • featured
  • Gambling Addiction
  • Holocaust
  • Law Practice Wellness
  • Law School
  • Lawyers
  • Mental Health
  • Opioid
  • Recovery
  • Stories
  • Suicide
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Videos

Recent Posts

As Sick As Our Secrets
08Feb,2021
Sobriety at 60
11Jan,2021
Changing The World With Acts of Kindness
31Dec,2020

Get in touch

brian@briancuban.com

Useful Links

  • Home
  • Meet Brian Cuban
  • Contact
  • Recovery, Wellness and CLE Presentations

Social Links

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google Plus
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube

Brian’s Newsletter

Subscribe to get updates right in your inbox. We promise to not send you spam.

Brian Cuban supported by EBW Technology.